On November 17, 2026, the Federal Circuit decided Cocona, Inc. v. VF Outdoor, LLC, Nos. 2025-1458 and 2025-1462, in a precedential opinion on appeal from the District of Colorado (Nos. 1:16-cv-02703 and 1:17-cv-01195, Judge Christine M. Arguello). Cocona sued VF Outdoor, LLC, which does business as The North Face, and Columbia Sportswear Company for infringing U.S. Patent No. 8,945,287, which the opinion says claims a waterproof, breathable material. The district court held the asserted claims invalid as indefinite, and the Federal Circuit affirmed (Op. 2). Circuit Judge Stark wrote for a panel that also included Circuit Judges Lourie and Stoll.
The limitation at issue
Cocona asserted claims 1, 38, and 39. Each recites a moisture vapor transmission rate (MVTR) "from about 600 g/m2/day to about 11000 g/m2/day" (Op. 3-6). Earlier, in an inter partes review brought by VF Outdoor, the Board found the challenged claims other than claims 38 and 39 unpatentable as obvious, and the Federal Circuit affirmed in 2021 (Op. 4).
The specification identifies three potential methods for measuring MVTR: the Mocon method, the upright cup method, and the inverted cup method. It says MVTR "may be measured" under ASTM E96-94 at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20% relative humidity (Op. 3-4, 9). The court wrote that the claims "give no clue as to whether to use the upright or inverted cup method, or both, or what temperature and humidity conditions to set for whichever test one performs" (Op. 8).
What the court held
The court pointed to the patent's own test data. A control sample measured 470 g/m2/day by the upright cup method, outside the claimed range, and 6,356 g/m2/day by the inverted cup method, inside it. In the provisional application, incorporated by reference, sample 41-6-4 measured 1,394 g/m2/day inverted and 223 g/m2/day upright (Op. 11). Quoting Dow Chemical Co. v. Nova Chemicals Corp., the court repeated that "the existence of multiple methods leading to different results without guidance in the patent or the prosecution history as to which method should be used renders the claims indefinite" (Op. 12).
The court said it was not holding that a claim is "per se indefinite" whenever a patent contemplates more than one measuring method. Its holding was limited to "the specific context of the '287 patent" (Op. 9). It found no clear error in the district court's decision to credit the expert for VF Outdoor and Columbia over Cocona's expert, whose testimony the district court called "quintessentially conclusory" (Op. 13). It also rejected Cocona's reliance on Presidio and Ethicon, its argument that the patent requires testing at 40 degrees and 20% humidity, and its argument that the district court applied the wrong legal standard (Op. 14-16).
The opinion ends "AFFIRMED" (Op. 16).