On November 18, 2026, the Federal Circuit decided Edge Systems LLC v. Cartessa Aesthetics, LLC, Nos. 2025-1119 and 2025-1190, in a nonprecedential opinion on appeal from the Eastern District of New York (No. 2:20-cv-06082, Judge Gary R. Brown). Edge sued Cartessa in December 2020, alleging that Cartessa's Skinwave system infringed U.S. Patent No. 9,550,052, which the opinion says concerns a system for skin treatment (Op. 2-3). The district court granted summary judgment of noninfringement and of no invalidity (Op. 4), and on October 15, 2024 entered final judgment in accordance with a stipulation of the parties (Op. 5; ECF No. 110). The Federal Circuit vacated the noninfringement judgment, remanded, and affirmed the no-invalidity judgment (Op. 2). Circuit Judge Prost wrote for a panel that also included Circuit Judges Hughes and Cunningham.
The manifold dispute
Claim 1, which the court treated as representative, recites a console including a "manifold" in fluid communication with a first fluid container and at least a second fluid container (Op. 2). The parties had agreed the term needed no construction, but at summary judgment Cartessa argued the manifold must be able to "combin[e] multiple sources into a single outlet," while Edge argued it was simply "a component with one outlet and several inlets, for connecting with other pipes" (Op. 3). Edge conceded that under Cartessa's view the Skinwave system does not meet claim 1 (Op. 3, 6-7). The district court reproduced Edge's annotated image of the Skinwave system, with a white box labeled as the manifold, and observed that Edge did not meaningfully dispute Cartessa's argument that Edge's expert "remained unaware of [the white box's] internal structure and composition, did not detach [it] from the console, did no destructive testing and could not remember even touching [it]" (Op. 4). It deemed the competing views of "manifold" irrelevant, concluding that Edge's evidentiary shortcomings meant that, "however one might construe the functions of a manifold, Edge cannot prove that the Skinwave device contains one" (Op. 4-5).
The Federal Circuit disagreed that construing "manifold" was unnecessary. Under Edge's construction, the court said it believed that "a reasonable jury could find the relevant claim element(s) satisfied," at least with reference to an image from the district court's order (Op. 6). It remanded for the district court to resolve the construction dispute in the first instance and rejected Cartessa's waiver argument (Op. 7-8). It declined to take up Cartessa's alternative grounds for affirmance, including that the Skinwave system lacks the claimed "fluid communication" and that Cartessa is not a direct infringer, and said the district court may consider them on remand (Op. 8). In remanding, the court noted that a court is not bound to accept either party's preferred construction, and it added that "to whatever extent the proper construction of 'manifold' requires knowledge of internal structure or functionality (as opposed to something externally observable or provable), Edge's evidentiary limitations will likely be that much more relevant" (Op. 8).
Invalidity
According to the opinion, Edge observed that Cartessa's only invalidity defense was anticipation by U.S. Patent No. 6,162,232 (Shadduck) (Op. 4). The court affirmed the summary judgment of no invalidity. It held that no reasonable jury could find by clear and convincing evidence that Shadduck discloses a system configured to let a user "select the treatment material [comprising a liquid] from the first fluid container or the at least second fluid container," as claim 1 requires (Op. 8-9). It noted that it is unclear whether the district court relied on that ground, and that it may affirm on a ground supported in the record (Op. 9). The court said Shadduck's trigger lets a user select between gas and gas-plus-liquid, while claim 1 requires selecting between "liquid" and "liquid" treatment materials, so the trigger does not satisfy that element (Op. 10-11).
The disposition reads "VACATED-IN-PART, AFFIRMED-IN-PART, AND REMANDED," with costs to Edge (Op. 11).