On November 20, 2026, the Federal Circuit affirmed in a nonprecedential opinion the District of Delaware's Rule 12(b)(6) dismissal of Fraud Free Transactions LLC's infringement suit against Ping Identity Corp. The court agreed that the claims of U.S. Patents No. 11,551,215 and No. 12,093,950, both titled "Fraud Deterrence for Secure Transactions," are directed to patent-ineligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C. 101. Circuit Judge Linn wrote for a panel that also included Circuit Judges Taranto and Cunningham. The appeal came from No. 1:24-cv-01218-GBW before Judge Gregory Brian Williams.
The '215 patent
The parties agreed that claim 22 is representative of the '215 patent claims (Op. 3). The court said the claim recites the generic steps and results of receiving a request to access software, communicating with a fraud prevention application installed on a predefined mobile phone, obtaining approval or denial through that application, and displaying a pop-up notification (Op. 5). Relying on Universal Secure Registry LLC v. Apple Inc., it agreed the claim is directed to the abstract idea of "preventing fraud by requiring identity verification from multiple sources" and lacks an inventive concept (Op. 4-8). It held that CosmoKey Solutions GmbH & Co. KG v. Duo Security LLC did not help Fraud Free, because claim 22 "requires no comparable operational constraints beyond obtaining approval or denial through the application on the predefined mobile phone" (Op. 7).
The '950 patent
The parties agreed that claims 1 and 2 are representative of the '950 patent claims (Op. 3). The court described claim 1 as reciting "a plurality of configurable rules" that evaluate an access request's originating IP address, device identifier, and geographic location to decide whether to permit access or require varying levels of multifactor authentication (Op. 8-9). Citing FairWarning IP, LLC v. Iatric Systems, Inc., the court agreed the claims are directed to "adjusting identification requirements based on the risk associated with a transaction" (Op. 8-9). It said conventionality is relevant at Alice step two, but held that even accepting Fraud Free's allegations that the rules were unconventional, "their asserted novelty lies in the abstract authentication process itself, not in a distinct technological implementation" (Op. 10-11). The disposition: "AFFIRMED" (Op. 11).