On November 19, 2026, the Federal Circuit issued two nonprecedential opinions affirming the dismissal of suits over U.S. Patent No. 6,182,128, which the opinions say expired on March 5, 2018. Ziklag IP LLC brought the appeals, Nos. 2025-1733, 2025-1734, and 2025-1960, from the Northern District of Illinois. Circuit Judge Stoll wrote both opinions for a panel that also included Circuit Judges Lourie and Stark.
According to the opinions, Touchmusic Entertainment LLC filed the suits against Apple Inc., Amazon Web Services, Inc., and Netflix, Inc. in March 2024, while its corporate rights were suspended under California law. On April 18, 2024, Touchmusic assigned certain rights in the '128 patent to the newly incorporated Ziklag, and amended complaints substituted Ziklag as plaintiff. In each case, the district court held that Ziklag did not receive the right to sue for past damages, which the opinions say was fatal because the patent had long expired.
Netflix
In Touchmusic Entertainment LLC v. Netflix, Inc., No. 2025-1960 (No. 1:24-cv-01789, Judge Mary M. Rowland), Ziklag did not challenge the past-damages ruling. It appealed only the denial of leave to amend to put Touchmusic back in as plaintiff. The district court had found the substitution "was done for tactical advantage to avoid the issue of Touchmusic's suspended corporate status." The Federal Circuit found no abuse of discretion under Rule 17 and, even considering Rule 15(a), none under that rule and affirmed (Netflix Op. 4-8).
Apple and Amazon
In Touchmusic Entertainment LLC v. Apple Inc., Nos. 2025-1733 and 2025-1734 (Nos. 1:24-cv-01786 and 1:24-cv-01787, Judge Steven C. Seeger), Ziklag did challenge the past-damages ruling. The court held Ziklag was collaterally estopped from doing so, because the Netflix district court had already decided the same issue in a separate, unconsolidated case before a different judge, and Ziklag did not challenge that ruling in its Netflix appeal. The court said that if it reversed on the merits, "two entities would simultaneously own an undivided right to sue for past damages, which cannot be correct." It affirmed (Apple Op. 4-8).