On November 16, 2026, the Federal Circuit decided Traxcell Technologies, LLC v. Cellco Partnership, Nos. 2025-1496 and 2025-1683, in a precedential opinion on appeal from the Western District of Texas (No. 6:24-mc-00613-ADA, Judge Alan D Albright). Traxcell had brought an independent action there seeking to void a judgment of the Eastern District of Texas that awarded attorneys' fees under 35 U.S.C. 285. The Western District entered judgment denying Traxcell relief on the merits. The court wrote: "We conclude that we have appellate jurisdiction. But because we determine the District Court for the Western District of Texas did not have jurisdiction, we vacate the judgment and remand with instructions to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction" (Op. 2). Circuit Judge Dyk wrote for a panel that also included Circuit Judges Chen and Stoll.

How the case got here

According to the opinion, Traxcell sued in the Eastern District of Texas on October 31, 2017, alleging infringement of U.S. Patent Nos. 8,977,284, 9,510,320, 9,642,024, and 9,549,388. The opinion refers to the defendant in that case and Cellco Partnership, dba Verizon Wireless, together as Verizon. The district court held some asserted claims indefinite and, on April 15, 2020, granted Verizon summary judgment of noninfringement on the remaining claims. The Federal Circuit affirmed in Traxcell Techs., LLC v. Sprint Commc'ns Co., 15 F.4th 1121 (Fed. Cir. 2021). On December 22, 2022, the district court awarded Verizon attorneys' fees under section 285. The Federal Circuit affirmed that award in a Rule 36 judgment, Traxcell Techs., LLC v. AT&T Inc., No. 23-1246 (Fed. Cir. July 13, 2023), and the Supreme Court denied certiorari (Op. 2-3 and n.1).

Traxcell then filed an emergency motion for relief from judgment in the Eastern District, arguing for the first time that the Federal Circuit's mandate in the 2021 appeal barred the later fee award. The opinion says that motion is still pending. Traxcell also filed an independent action under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(d)(1) against Verizon in the Western District of Texas, making substantially the same arguments. After the Western District denied a preliminary injunction against enforcement of the fee award, the parties stipulated to final judgment against Traxcell's independent-action claim, subject to Traxcell's right to appeal (Op. 3-4).

What the court held

The court rejected Verizon's suggestion that it lacked appellate jurisdiction. It wrote that Traxcell's action "is, on its face, an action to set aside a judgment for attorneys' fees under 35 U.S.C. § 285, a provision of the Patent Act," and that the case "is akin to a declaratory judgment action of no liability" (Op. 4-5).

Although the parties did not raise it, the court considered the Western District's jurisdiction and gave two grounds for finding it lacking. First, under United States v. Beggerly, 524 U.S. 38 (1998), an independent action "should be available only to prevent a grave miscarriage of justice." The court wrote that "[u]nder Beggerly, a district court lacks jurisdiction over an independent action if the allegations of the complaint fail to meet the high standard for an independent action." It said Traxcell's briefing did not cite Beggerly, and that "[t]he frivolous theory that the Eastern District of Texas lacked jurisdiction to award attorneys' fees does not come close to satisfying the grave-miscarriage-of-justice standard." It added that Traxcell had not raised a jurisdictional argument in the earlier fee proceeding (Op. 6-8). Second, the court held that "one district court may not entertain an independent action to set aside another district court's judgment that has been affirmed on appeal, whether or not the Beggerly standard is satisfied." It wrote that Traxcell's action "seeks to countermand a judgment already affirmed by this court," and that "[a] district court has no jurisdiction over an independent action or Rule 60 cause of action seeking to overturn an order of a court of appeals" (Op. 8-10).

In its conclusion, the court wrote that it had appellate jurisdiction over Traxcell's case "because it arises under federal patent law," that "the district court did not have jurisdiction over Traxcell's independent action," and that it would "vacate the district court's judgment and remand with instructions to dismiss the case for want of jurisdiction." The opinion ends "VACATED AND REMANDED," with costs to Verizon (Op. 10).